| | 2008-2009 Individual Results (Red) |
| | Name | School | | Points |
| | Leo Kirsch | LE | | 144 |
| | Nick Rankovich | LE | | 120 |
| | Robby Mirabal | ST | | 107 |
| | Tim Murphy | AN | | 101.5 |
| | Matt Osuch | LE | | 93.5 |
| | Mike Retzlaff | LE | | 91 |
| | William Johnson | LE | | 80 |
| | Peter Nelson | ST | | 80 |
| | Moath Jaber | ST | | 74 |
| | Chris Johnson | LE | | 72 |
| | Matt Johnson | ST | | 69 |
| | Ken Schuldt | ST | | 63 |
| | Bob Connolly | AN | | 58 |
| | Khalil Hasan | ST | | 56 |
| | John Joyce | AN | | 53 |
| | Brian Jozwiak | BO | | 48 |
| | Anna Hausmann | AN | | 47 |
| | Jake McAuliffe | AN | | 45.5 |
| | Corey Fisher | LE | | 42 |
| | Alex Pacura | ST | | 41 |
| | Sean McKenzie (JV) | LK | | 40 |
| | Jonathan Lopez-Tyhala | AN | | 37 |
| | Dan Rex | AN | | 36 |
| | Jeff Dudek | AN | | 33 |
| | Matt Bell | LE | | 30 |
| | William Byar (JV) | LK | | 28 |
| | Luke Kozak (JV) | LK | | 26 |
| | Jessica Hyker | ST | | 22 |
| | Chris Pendleton | ST | | 21 |
| | Tom Ricketts | AN | | 20 |